Planned Obsolescence

Buddha_lantau There is a  saying, supposedly Buddhist, that “when the student is ready, the teacher will appear”.  This week in #rhizo14 we are looking at the opposite to this  – how should the teacher disappear – how do we empower our learners to begin to think for themselves?  It’s something that I try to do in my tutorials by using the Jigsaw Technique and a neo-Vygotskian approach to learning which means that I begin the year with fairly structured activities for small group work and, as the semester progresses, I gradually provide less and less support.  My proudest moment was when a group told me that they didn’t need me to hang around at the end of a class, they could carry on without me.  And then they did.

Cat_on_the_ladder_1A metaphor I often use when I am teaching, especially when I am working with adult learners, is that of a ladder.  I like to think that I started somewhere near the bottom and that, in some way, I have climbed up some way.  Maybe it’s not very rhizomatic, but I find it helps to explain to some folk the thought that “experts” are not more intelligent than “novices”, they have just had longer to learn and become familiar with subject matter.

And, or course, it allows me to quote one of my favourite parts of one of my favourite thinkers:

My propositions are elucidatory in this way: he who understands me finally recognizes them as senseless, when he has climbed out through them, on them, over them. (He must so to speak throw away the ladder, after he has climbed up on it.)
He must surmount these propositions; then he sees the world
rightly.  Wittgenstein. Tractatus Section 6.54

Need I say more?

This entry was posted in #rhizo14, Academia, Learning, Wittgenstein and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Planned Obsolescence

  1. Freud speaking of the study of dreams:
    “It may be that this first portion of our psychological study of dreams will leave us with a sense of dissatisfaction. But we can console ourselves with the thought that we have been obliged to build our way out into the dark.” Freud The Interpretation of Dreams
    I love the idea of Freud being his own expert and confronting the unknown. I wonder if people want that much responsibility? Do they dare kick away the ladder and venture on? Have to read up on the neo-Vygotskian approach. Love the zone of proximal development. Especially because it’s a zone it can be reached from many directions.

  2. Perfect end to a perfect experience. See you in the rhizome!

  3. balimaha says:

    Loved this post, Sarah

Leave a Reply